What Is a Bible Worth?

Anglican Journal tells of Janet Carlile, an accredited antique appraiser, who regularly assesses items at fund-raising events for charitable organizations such as public libraries and local museums. Bibles come up frequently. She knows that while they are “near and dear to people’s hearts, the majority are worth less than $50 and some a good deal less.”

In a career spanning three decades, the most expensive Bible she recalls sold for $1,200 and it was a very unusual volume. Such Bibles make the news but are a rarity. The article continues:

People bring Bibles to Ms. Carlile because they are often the oldest item in their homes. Tucked away in a cupboard in my parents’ den is a set of Swedish Bibles brought here by my maternal great great-grandparents when they immigrated. Although the language was lost many generations ago, the Bibles were not. Their yellowed pages, brittle leather binding, and foreign words belie their status as an heirloom. They are the only tangible link with our Swedish heritage and as such are valued.

Many Bibles are big, beautiful books. Produced in large quantities and instant best-sellers, publishers can afford to use fine quality materials. According to the staff at the Master’s Way Book Store in Pembroke, Ont., Bibles are a popular gift to commemorate a first communion or confirmation milestone. New translations are always sought after and the Catholic Bible and King James Version are perpetually in demand.

Some people cherish a Bible even though it is an unremarkable edition because it was a source of comfort, strength, or advice at an emotional time. Bev York, a lay reader and pillar of St. Augustine’s church in Beachburg, Ont., treasures her Bible because she relied on it through trying times of illness and bereavement. Then, and at countless other times, the words offered her solace and hope. She also holds dear a Bible that belonged to her mother and one that she rescued from a garbage chute. Although Ms. York has worn Bibles out, she won’t throw them away, preferring instead to give them to someone else, especially a new believer.

For Christian faith communities, a Bible is a collection of sacred writings. The content between the covers is the source of value, not the trappings. This leads to an answer to my original question: a Bible has an incalculable worth.

Incalculable worth. But unlike other valuable books, the Bible is worth more when it is in worse condition. The pristine copy with unmarred gold foil edges and a fine layer of dust is practically worthless compared to the dog eared copy with coffee stains and some portions underlined in pen and others marked with tears.