Irenic Thoughts

Irenic. The word means peaceful. This web log (or blog) exists to create an ongoing, and hopefully peaceful, series of comments on the life of King of Peace Episcopal Church. This is not a closed community. You are highly encouraged to comment on any post or to send your own posts.

5/26/2006

eU2charist

Photo from a eU2charist

This announcement is from St. Paul's Episcopal Church in Jesup, Georgia:
It is in the spirit of this diversity that I am pleased to announce a very special evening in the life of St. Paul’s. On Friday, June 2nd at 7PM, we will be offering a service which is known as the U2 Eucharist. Basically, it is a service which uses the communion liturgy from “Enriching Our Worship” along with “hymns” of recorded songs from the fabulous and timeless rock band U2. The congregation is invited to sing along – the words are printed in the bulletin – as loudly and enthusiastically as we can. Because Bono, U2's lead singer, has probably the strongest voice and the greatest tonal range of any singer alive, we can all relax knowing that our voices will be beautifully and powerfully led!

Please spread the word about this unique evening. The excitement and buzz is already spreading through Jesup and the entire Diocese so let’s make sure that everyone who would enjoy this worship experience is invited and welcomed..

One last thing. I heard someone here at St. Paul’s said, “If we can do U2, when are we doing a Merle Haggard service?” All I can say to that is that I’m already on it – although I think Johnny Cash might work better...
This U2-inspired communion service is very much of the moment. Haven't heard of it yet? There are typical news articles on an Episcopal church's u2charist here: Church holds U2 Eucharist and here: ‘U2charist’ gains worldwide fame .

Over at Sarah Laughed, Dylan who "was among the organizers of a eU2charist in April of 2004, and was a contributor to Get Up Off Your Knees: Preaching the U2 Catalog", writes a thoughtful post U2 and Liturgy. She writes
Preaching inspired by U2 and the GospelSometimes people experience shows where something goes "wrong" as the best shows of all because of the ways in which one person's weakness brings out another's strength. The Edge sings lead vocals for a verse or a song when Bono's voice is gone. The rhythm section keeps the song going when a key guitar string breaks. The crowd's energy carries Bono along when his father has died and Bono's grief is fresh and raw, and strength is surprisingly made perfect in weakness.
While Dylan is particularly good in the way she writes about U2 and liturgy, this sort of thinking is common around the web, particularly among those in what are sometimes called the emergent church. Here's another example: 7 things I learnt from Bono about worship leading.

If you want to experience this form of communion for yourself, the service in Jesup is a pleasant evening drive away. The Rev. Chris Schuller and the congregation at St. Paul's will enjoy worshipping with you.

As for me, I listen to U2 with some regularity and certainly I get what those who put on a eU2charist are talking about when they connect to the spirituality in the band's music and the liturgical nature of their concerts. Yet, I am not jumping on the bandwagon to create a similar worship service at King of Peace. Done well, I imagine it could be quite moving. Done poorly, it would be an embarassing dip into the Spirit of the Age, which we would all laugh about in later years. What do you think?

peace,
Frank+
The Rev. Frank Logue, Pastor + King of Peace Episcopal Church

Dylan is in the yellow circle in this concert photo

5 Comments:

  • At 5/26/2006 12:30 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    What happens when we replace the hymn sung by angels and archangels and all the company of heaven with one that is sung by rockers and rappers and all the company of the mosh pit? That may not be fair - God knows the Church has Christianized many pagan things and we can Christianize rock-n-roll. But my concern is whether the eu2charist is catching on because the words are far and beyond a theological gem or if because people like the music of U2 and think Bono is a great guy? I read somewhere that the Church can try to give people what they want but the problem is - the people don't know what they want. My other question is, and Celeste has brought this up, how do you move youth and the unchurched who have been brought in by the eu2charist to the principal service of the Eucharist that is not U2? Can they go from Bono to Prayer B? I don't know. It will be interesting to see.

     
  • At 5/27/2006 8:58 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Thanks Frank.

    I confess I have never written a blog or a comment on any blogsite so it was fun to see the U2 Service description on yours. As one of the K. of P. bloggers mentioned, the service is mainly gauged at reaching folks who have never set foot in a church. I am also convinced that there are a number of people who aren't fed by much of contemporary Christian music but who are stirred by what we've placed outside the "sacred music" fence. For me, Rock n' Roll has been the most consistent and reliable door to God since I was 8 years old. When Nirvana plays and I hear Kurt Cobain scream out every known emotion in a single song, I'm hearing Holy Spirit even though I know the same song to others might sound like proof of Satan's existence.

    As for getting this service right, or doing it well, please keep us in your prayers. Unlike the photo on your blog-site, we won't have projected lyrics and graphics, but I am sure we will have joy and prayer-filled hearts. We also have great acoustics in the sanctuary so we know the music will sound really good at just a medium volume. It will all be in the name of Love. Also, if you think it matters to folks, you can tell them that the offering will go to Bono's D.A.T.A. (Debt, AIDS, Trade, Africa) charity.

    Again thanks.
    Peace, Chris

     
  • At 5/28/2006 2:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    We went to Dublin right after 9/11, and one thing that gave me the creeps was that the words people used to describe Bono was "our Messiah". A good man, yes, but Messiah?.... I don't think so.

     
  • At 5/03/2008 11:35 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Many thanks for your irenic thoughts on the U2charist!

    Since you link to some articles with factual inaccuracies about this, I'd be very grateful if you clarified that that the U2charist didn't start in 2005 in Maine, but rather the first public service was held in 2004 in Baltimore, Maryland -- and the bishops of the Episcopal Diocese of Maryland deserve credit for making the keynote service of the diocesan clergy conference in 2004 a U2charist. The combination of the Internet, word of mouth, and the Maryland bishops' backing led to countless congregations adopting the U2charist (much to my astonishment, even as its creator!) being adopted from Maine to California as well as Canada to Australia and beyond.

    Info on the U2charist and how it started is available at the U2charist resources page and the U2charist FAQ. Please feel free to give me a shout if you'd like any more information, or if there's any other way I can be of help.

    Blessings,

    Dylan
    _________________
    Sarah Dylan Breuer
    http://www.sarahlaughed.net
    dylan@sarahlaughed.net

    "We live as though the world were what it should be, to show it what it can be." -- "Deep Down," *Angel* season 4

     
  • At 1/14/2010 9:54 PM, Blogger Douglas Bienert said…

    Now, I love U2. I think they are excellent musicians who explore Christian ideas in their music. I am often quite inspired by their work.

    However, their music is not appropriate for use in Divine worship. A Eucharist where U2 songs replace sacred hymns is ignorant foolishness at best, and sacrilege at worst. It simply is not a matter taste or emotions, but of theology. The goal of the Eucharist is to Sacramentally share in Christ's "...oblation of himself once offered, a full, perfect, and sufficient sacrifice, oblation, and satisfaction, for the sins of the whole world" (Book of Common Prayer).

    The hymns of the Church show us how U2 songs are not appropriate substitutions.

    4th century, Liturgy of Saint James

    Let all mortal flesh keep silence,
    And with fear and trembling stand;
    Ponder nothing earthly minded,
    For with blessing in His hand,
    Christ our God to earth descendeth,
    Our full homage to demand.

    Thomas Aquinas, 13th century.

    Therefore we, before him bending (not rocking)
    this great Sacrament revere;

    ...[it is] my duty is to exhort you to consider the dignity of that holy mystery, and the great peril of the unworthy receiving thereof (from the exhortation, Book of Common Prayer).

    "For the time will come when people will not put up with sound doctrine. Instead, to suit their own desires, they will gather around them a great number of teachers to say what their itching ears want to hear.

     

Post a Comment

<< Home